Reconceptualizing Idea-Expression Dichotomy through the Personality Theory: A Perspective on Generative AI and Ghibli Art

Authors

  • Debdeep Das W. B. National University of Juridical Sciences, Kolkata – 700 106, India
  • Mohar Mitra St. Xavier’s University, Kolkata – 700 160, India

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.56042/jipr.v31i6.27459

Keywords:

Studio Ghibli , Style, Idea-Expression Dichotomy, Generative AI Art, Character Delineation

Abstract

Art is a reflection of the artist’s mind, the repeated expression of which leads to the acquisition of a distinctive style so intrinsically linked to the artist that a mere glance can indicate the infusion of the artist’s personality. Although this link is present in all artistic works, it is magnified for artists who have profoundly impacted or influenced the field through recurrent expressions. Such artistic mastery is showcased by Studio Ghibli, who are known for using hand-drawn art to create immersive animations, resulting in the acquisition of immense fame, whilst inspiring future artists. However, recently, there have been several controversies around the creation of AI-generated artwork based on the Studio’s work. When viewed through the lens of copyright law, Studio Ghibli’s style does not qualify for protection due to the idea-expression dichotomy. From the perspective of moral rights jurisprudence, the artist is not afforded any stylistic rights since it is restricted to the right to attribution and integrity in the expression of the art. However, due to the AI-artwork’s intrinsic stylistic resemblance with Studio Ghibli’s expressions, the observers unmistakably draw a connection between the AI generated art and the Studio. This article ventures into the reconceptualization of the idea-expression dichotomy by 
doctrinally testing it against character delineation and the personality theory, deploying exploratory, analytical and comparative approaches to reimagine the protection of styles under the copyright law. It detects the roadblocks in the Indian copyright regime, suggests a contemporary standard for stylistic delineation through reinterpretation and enhancement of the originality standard with AI-generated works as the focal consideration.  

Downloads

Published

2026-11-20

How to Cite

Reconceptualizing Idea-Expression Dichotomy through the Personality Theory: A Perspective on Generative AI and Ghibli Art. (2026). Journal of Intellectual Property Rights (JIPR), 31(6), 1038-1047. https://doi.org/10.56042/jipr.v31i6.27459

Similar Articles

21-30 of 155

You may also start an advanced similarity search for this article.