Concerns of Copyright Protection in Metaverse: Study of the Jurisdictions of the United States of America and India
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.56042/jipr.v31i6.20885Keywords:
Metaverse,, Copyright, Fair Use Doctrine, Digital Authorship, Originality Threshold, Non-Fungible Tokens (NFTs), Joint Authorship, Fixation RequirementAbstract
This paper examines how established copyright doctrines originally designed to operate in the physical world operate within immersive virtual environments, also known as the metaverse, and evaluates whether current law requires reform to remain effective in this novel context. The central research question in this paper is ‘how do traditional rules of copyright law play out in the metaverse, and is there a need to change those rules to achieve in virtual worlds what they accomplish in the physical world?’ A subsidiary inquiry considers whether non-fungible tokens (NFTs) offer a viable mechanism to bridge gaps in digital ownership and enforcement. The analysis begins by tracing copyright’s historical adaptation to technology, spotlighting the emergence of fair use, the first-sale doctrine, and human-centered authorship. It then explores metaverse-specific challenges under four benchmarks. First, authorship must be a natural person, yet AI-generated and platform-assisted creations strain this requirement, leaving many virtual works not fit for copyright protection. Second, the originality threshold, which is the “modicum of creativity,” is tested by heavily derivative or auto-generated virtual assets, raising uncertainty about protectable expression. Third, joint authorship principles falter amid mass collaboration and blurred roles between users and platform providers, complicating ownership and licensing. Fourth, the fixation requirement confronts transient live performances and procedurally generated content, which may lack a stable, recordable form. Findings reveal that existing doctrines, although adaptable, leave significant enforcement and definitional gaps in the metaverse. NFTs represent a promising tool for digital property management but are not a panacea for all copyright challenges. The paper concludes that a combination of legal reform (clarifying AI authorship, digital exhaustion, and collaborative creations), international harmonization, and platform-level rights management will be required to secure creators’ rights and foster innovation in virtual worlds.